Industry

Restoration of Leith Hill oil drilling site would take 25 years

It would take 25 years to restore an exploratory oil site in the Surrey Hills after it was abandoned, a public inquiry heard this afternoon.

Landscape architect, Elizabeth Brown, said plans by Europa Oil and Gas to drill near Leith Hill in an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty would have a “significant adverse effect on the landscape”.

The drilling rig would be a prominent feature on the ridge line, she said, rising 15-20m above the tree tops. The site would be “incompatible with local land use and local landscape character”.

Mrs Brown was giving evidence on the first day of the inquiry into plans for an exploratory borehole at Bury Hill Wood. This morning it heard from three local residents who oppose the scheme. Our report.

This is the second public inquiry into Europa’s planning application. The first upheld the decision by Surrey County Council to refuse but this was overturned by the High Court.

Mrs Brown, who was giving evidence on behalf of the county council, said the landscape of the area was highly sensitive.

Sunken lanes, like parts of Coldharbour Lane, which would be used by heavy goods vehicles delivering to the site, were important cultural features of the landscape. Once they were changed it would be permanent she said. The site would also affect a view that was painted by the impressionist Pissarro

“You could not wholly reverse the impacts of the development”, she said. “It would take 25 years to replicate the appearance of that area”.

Mrs Brown said the drill site would diminish the character of the Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty and reduce the tranquillity of area, an important feature of the AONB.

Asked to define tranquillity, she said it was about being able to hear natural sounds, such as insects, birds or running water. Tranquillity was reduced by hearing noise from vehicles or machinery.

But she added that it was not just about noise. Absence of light was very important and being able to see the stars. She said a glow from the site would be visible at night.

Andrew Newcombe, for Europa Oil and Gas, put it to Mrs Brown that Surrey County Council’s landscape officer had not objected to the original planning application. Mrs Brown said the officer’s assessment had been based on guidance that was now out of date.

The inquiry continues tomorrow and is expected to end on 1st May

6 replies »

  1. So a painting by a minor artist years and years ago means that we can’t change the landscape for modern requirements? More important painted landscapes have been changed beyond all recognition and yet they are still tourist destinations. Elizabeth is scaremongering and painting [sic] the worst possible picture [sic].

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hay_Wain

  2. The applicant has not suggested that the borehole will go into production. Even if it did go into production it would produce only a small amount of oil for a short period of time. The United Kingdom has to take seriously all of its assets. One of those assets is the beauty of its diminishing but still cherished rural areas. For a demonstration of the seriousness with which responsible people choose to cherish rural beauty look no further than the actions of the community living in and around Leith Hill against the applicant Europa.

    • The UK has lots of rural areas, not really diminishing as they are protected by national parks. What is changing are farms which are getting fewer in number. But farms are basically open air factories with tons of industrial machinery used to maintain them, so not really that beautiful.

      • The community living in and around Leith Hill have demonstrated that they cherish the beauty they perceive to exist at Leith Hill.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s