Top 10 points on noise at Preston New Road – Cuadrilla fracking inquiry Day 9

Wednesday 21st August 2013. Balcombe South East England, UK. Cua

Dr Andrew McKenzie, the noise witness for Lancashire County Council said the Preston New Road development would have unacceptable noise impacts on local residents and could be refused because it did not comply with the Lancashire Minerals Plan and the Fylde Local Plan. These are the key points on noise from today’s hearing.

  1. Stress and sleep disturbance likely
    Dr McKenzie said the lowest achievable night time noise limits could still cause annoyance, stress and sleep disturbance at homes near the Preston New Road site. He said: “Stress and sleep disturbance will affect the ability of people to go about their everyday lives. I think this is very likely because of the nature of this development”. He added:

    “If consent is given it is in the knowledge that it will generate annoyance and that may cause stress.”

  2. Night time noise reduction an unreasonable burden – Cuadrilla
    Cuadrilla had offered to reduce night time noise at homes around Preston New Road to 39 decibels but it has withdrawn the offer, saying it is an unreasonable burden. The upper limit is now 42 decibels, the maximum in planning guidance for mineral developments.
  3. No guarantee night time noise limit of 42 decibels is achievable
    Dr McKenzie said there was a 15% chance that Cuadrilla would breach the 42 decibel limit and little more could be done because the company said further sound reduction would be an unreasonable burden.
  4. 42 decibel night time noise level breaks planning policy
    Planning policy required operators to minimise noise levels to avoid unacceptable impacts without imposing an unreasonable burden on the operator. Dr McKenzie said the 42 decibel level set by Cuadrilla was the maximum allowed by planning guidance so it “flies in the face of planning policy”.
  5. People acclimatise to noise quickly
    Cuadrilla’s barrister, Nathalie Lieven, told the inquiry: “People acclimatise to new noise sources pretty quickly.” Dr McKenzie said he thought this would be unlikely in this case.
  6. Chronic night time drilling noise
    Dr McKenzie said night time drilling noise would be chronic (long-term) for the people who were exposed to it. Their night times will be dominated by drilling for eight months, he said.
  7. Background noise exceeded for most of core sleep period
    Dr McKenzie said night time noise from the Preston New Road site would exceed current background noise levels for 92% of core sleep periods.
  8. Noise surveys inadequate
    Dr McKenzie told the inquiry the noise surveys for Preston New Road were not fit for purpose. They covered only one hour (Arup) or one day (Jacobs).
  9. Concerns about day time noise limits
    Cuadrilla proposed an upper limit of 55 decibels for day time noise at Preston New Road. Dr McKenzie said he was concerned about how this daytime noise limit had been arrived at.
  10. British Standard not appropriate for fracking
    The British Standard used by Cuadrilla, BS5228, applied to construction sites and not hydrocarbon drilling, Dr McKenzie said.

Live updates from Day 9

This report is part of DrillOrDrop’s  Rig Watch project.  Rig Watch receives funding from the Joseph Rowntree Reform Trust. More details here

2 replies »

Add a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s