Villagers opposed to drilling for oil in a remote part of the South Downs have accused regulators of a lack of robustness in handling the licence near their homes.
They say the Oil & Gas Authority (OGA), which controls the hydrocarbon licensing system, allowed an area north east of Portsmouth to move into the prized production phase without the usual requirements.
In response to a freedom of information request, the OGA said:
“In converting to 2014 Model clauses, the OGA used our discretion to allow the licence [for PEDL126] into the Production Term, which will expire on 30/06/2034.”
The licence area of PEDL126 covers an area of about 5.5km by 2km between Petersfield and Emsworth on the West Sussex-Hampshire border.
The licence operator, UK Oil & Gas (UKOG), now has the authority to produce oil from the area, subject to planning permission and consent from the Environment Agency.
UKOG has a well site in PEDL126 at Markwells Wood, but no work has been carried out there since 2011.
Markwells Wood Watch, a residents’ group established to oppose production plans at the site, has now called on the government to block the licence.
The group said:
“Markwells Wood Watch is very concerned by the Oil and Gas Authority’s management of PEDL126 as evidenced in recent freedom of information requests.
“It appears that the OGA have not been robust in their examination of the history of the site nor the phases and requirements before passing it into production phase.”
DrillOrDrop asked the OGA under which legislation it was able to use its discretion to move licences into production. The OGA, now a government company in which the Energy Secretary is the sole shareholder, chose to treat the question as another freedom of information request. This post will be updated with the OGA’s response.
What the licence rules say
Onshore oil and gas licences usually have three stages: initial (also called exploration), second (also called appraisal) and third (or production).
According to OGA licence rules, the licence will expire after the initial phase, usually five years, unless the operator has completed the agreed work programme and surrendered part of the licence area.
At the end of the second phase, the licence will expire unless the OGA has approved a development plan.
What happened in PEDL126
Documents released under the FOI response reveal that PEDL126 had two extensions to its first phase and two extensions to the second phase.
PEDL126 documents released under FOI request (pdf)
On 28 June 2016, a document from the OGA stated that the production phase would begin on 30 June 2016. UKOG would keep the whole of the licence, known as the retention area. The work programme for the production phase required UKOG to submit a Field Development Plan by 30 June 2017.
Two weeks later, however, UKOG asked the OGA to change the work programme.
On 27 July 2016, the OGA agreed to new licence arrangements. The licence area of PEDL126 remained the same but under the “retention area plan” UKOG committed to submit a planning application by 31 December 2016, drill a horizontal well by 30 June 2020 and submit the Markwells Wood Field Development Plan by 30 June 2021.
In its FOI response, the OGA said:
“A Retention Area Work Plan replaced the requirement for an approved Field Development Plan required at the end of the Second Term of the licence in 2016.”
UKOG submitted a planning application in September 2016 for new wells, testing and production at Markwells Wood. But the application was never determined.
On 2 May 2017, the South Downs National Park Authority announced that UKOG had withdrawn the application. The Environment Agency and Portsmouth Water had objected to the plans because of the risk to groundwater. DrillOrDrop report
UKOG said it would submit a revised application by the end of 2017. But as the year closed, UKOG had not told its investors that it had submitted an application for Markwells Wood and none had been published by the South Downs National Park Authority.
“Licence should be terminated”
In response to the OGA’s decision over PEDL126, Markwells Wood Watch said it was:
“requesting that the Secretary of State for Energy, Greg Clark, terminate the Retention Area Plan due to UKOGs non-compliance with its Work Programme.”
The group said:
“The water in our area is some of the most pure in England. It is our biggest asset and no risk is acceptable. We have been arguing for the restoration of the site since September 2016 and will continue our campaign until the well is properly abandoned and the site is fully restored.”
Timeline of extensions for PEDL126 and Markwells Wood
Source: PEDL126 documents released under FOI request (pdf), FOI response and planning application register
1 July 2003
PEDL126 commenced for an Initial Term of six years expiring 30 June 2009
19 June 2007
West Sussex County Council validates planning application n (SO/3152/07) from Northern Petroleum for a temporary hydrocarbon exploration site
10 March 2009
Deed of variation to extend Initial Term of PEDL126 licence to seven years to expire 30 June 2010; Second Term to be four years (expiring 30 June 2014) and production phase for a maximum of 20 years (2034)
22 April 2010
Deed of variation to extend Initial Term of PEDL126 licence to eight years to expire 30 June 2011; Second Term to be three years (expiring 30 June 2014)
21 November 2010
Northern Petroleum announces Markwells Wood-1 well spudded at 15.00 hours
7 September 2011
Northern Petroleum announces extended well test at Markwells Wood-1
23 January 2013
West Sussex County Council issues a decision notice approving the application WSCC/011/12/SO/SDNP for an extension of planning permission until 31 March 2013
22 November 2013
South Downs National Park Authority approves extension of planning permission for another two years until 31 March 2015
23 June 2014
Deed of variation to extend Second Term of PEDL126 licence to four years to expire on 30 June 2015; production phase reduced from 20 to 19 years (expiring 30 June 2034)
20 October 2014
UKOG completes acquisition of Northern Petroleum’s UK interests including PEDL126
13 April 2015
UKOG announces it has bought the 40% stake in PEDL126 held by Magellan Petroleum UK
7 May 2015
Deed of variation to extend Second Term of PEDL126 licence to five years to expire on 30 June 2016; production phase reduced from 19 to 18 years (expiring 30 June 2034).
14 October 2015
South Downs National Park Authority grants extension of planning permission until 31 September 2016
20 May 2016
UKOG asks the OGA to create a Retention Area for PEDL126
28 June 2016
Deed of variation states the production period is the period of 18 years beginning on the day after the Second Term ends (30 June 2016) and expiring 30 June 2034
29 June 2016
Letter from OGA to UKOG approves the proposed retention area: the entire licenced area of PEDL126. The retention area plan is to submit a Field Development Plan for Markwells Wood-1 discovery by 30 June 2017.
11 July 2016
UKOG asks the OGA to modify the Work Programme for the Retention Area of PEDL126, created on 29 June 2016
27 July 2016
Letter from OGA to UKOG responding to request for modification to Work Programme for the Retention Area created on 29 June 2016. Geographic area of the retention area is the entire licenced area of PEDL126. The expiry date is 30 June 2021. The Retention Area Plan is to submit a planning application for an appraisal well by 31 December 2016, drill a horizontal well by 30 June 2020 and submit Markwells Wood Field Development Plan by 30 June 2021.
20 September 2016
South Downs National Park Authority validates application for a sidetrack well off Markwells Wood-1, three new hydrocarbon wells, a water injection well, flow testing and production for 20 years
2 May 2017
South Downs National Park Authority announces UKOG has withdrawn planning application. Environment Agency and Portsmouth Water had objected to plans because of risk to groundwater
16 October 2017
UKOG said it would resubmit a new planning application by the end of 2017 DrillOrDrop report
31 December 2017
UKOG has not reported to its shareholders that it has submitted a planning application for Markwells Wood and no application has been published by the South Downs National Park Authority
Just to point out Martin C, that the UK has lost most of its refining capability. A large amount of our petrol and diesel now comes from Rotterdam. We have also lost maybe 90% of our downstream petrochemicals industry. As seen in the USA, the new tight oil/gas reserves trigger huge repatriation of these industries once a low cost/secure feed stock resource is in place. Exactly the same could happen here. INEOS are trying very hard to make this happen. Frankly, it can’t happen quickly enough.