Angus Energy submits new planning application for Brockham


Brockham oil site. Photo: Weald Oil Watch

Surrey County Council has confirmed that Angus Energy submitted a planning application today for its oil site at Brockham near Dorking.

The submission had been expected since the company told investors in October it was preparing an application.

It has not yet been published. But a council document seen by DrillOrDrop suggests the application covers the drilling of a sidetrack well in January 2017 but not commercial production from it.

The application is the latest stage in a planning dispute between the company and the council over the sidetrack, called BRX4Z.

The company has argued consistently that it had planning permission to drill and produce oil from BRX4Z. The council maintained that neither drilling nor production from the sidetrack was covered by existing planning permissions.

At the time of writing, Angus Energy has not issued a statement to investors about the application.

Surrey County Council

Surrey County Council headquarters in Kingston. Photo: DrillOrDrop

Timeline to an application

1 August 2017

The Oil and Gas Authority (OGA) contacts Surrey County Council about Angus Energy’s application to complete [make it capable of flowing hydrocarbons] the BRX4Z sidetrack well. The OGA invites the council to discuss the planning dispute. Link

7 August 2017

Angus Energy tells OGA it intends to “conduct a trial production period to gather long term production performance information” on the Brockham X4Z (the sidetrack). Link

It quoted from an addendum to its Field Development Plan:

“The well will be initially put into production using underbalanced perforating and with downhole gauges present.

12 October 2017

The OGA approves completion work on the BRX4Z well. Link

20 October 2017

Formal production consent from the OGA for the Brockham site. LInk

23 October 2017

Angus says in a statement to investors it has the go-ahead from the Oil & Gas Authority to produce oil from the Kimmeridge layers in the BRX4Z well, starting with a 200m section of interbedded shale and limestone.

25 October 2017

In another statement to shareholders on 25 October, Angus says it will submit a planning application to Surrey County Council for the BRX4Z sidetrack:

“After a careful and considered review, the Management team and Board of Directors of Angus Energy will, as Operator of the license, submit a normalisation application for the continued surface activities of the production plant required for well BR-X4 and notably, its inclusive sidetrack BR-X4Z.”

The company also says it will begin production from the Kimmeridge in the first quarter of 2018.

Also on this day, Angus submits a screening request to Surrey County Council. This is one of the first stages in the planning application process. The company set out what it was applying for and asked the council to rule on whether an environmental impact assessment was needed.

According to a Surrey County Council document, Angus Energy was seeking a screening opinion on:

  • The retention of the BRX-4 wellhead for a period of up to three years;
  • The drilling of a sidetrack well (BRX-4Z) from the existing BRX-4 wellhead, to assess the longer term production prospects of the Portland Sandstone, and to collect data from the deeper Kimmeridge horizons;
  • Production evaluation of the BRX-4Z sidetrack well, to determine whether the flow and volume of oil would support commercial production.

The company said of its proposal:

“In order to assess BRX4Z it will be subject to an extended period of production evaluation in order to confirm whether the volume & flow of oil is economically viable to support commercial production. In order to allow sufficient time to complete this process, permission will be sought for a 3 year period. Wherever possible these works will utilise the existing site infrastructure.”

7 November 2017

The council responds with its screening opinion that an EIA is not needed. Surrey County Council screening opinion on Brockham Wellsite (07-11-17)

One of the reasons for this is the conclusion that the proposed development will not include production. The screening opinion says:

“The development would involve an evaluation of the productive potential of the BRX-4Z well, but would not involve commercial hydrocarbon production.”

This is repeated several times throughout the document, including:

“The proposal to undertake production evaluation of the BRX-4Z sidetrack well would not involve the extraction of hydrocarbons (oil) at a commercial rate, but would seek to establish the rate and volume of flows from the well to ascertain whether such future production might be commercially viable.”


“The proposal to undertake production evaluation of the BRX-4Z sidetrack well would not involve the extraction of hydrocarbons (oil) at a commercial rate.”

Questions over permission

A planning application for an oil and gas that does not need an environmental impact assessment should, under government guidelines, usually be decided within 13 weeks.

Technically, this new application from Angus Energy could be decided by the end of the first quarter of 2018, assuming it is validated quickly by the council and there are no delays.

But assuming that the application is consistent with the screening opinion this won’t give permission for commercial production from the BRX4Z.

Surrey County Council has confirmed that the company has not submitted any other screening requests.

DrillOrDrop asked Angus Energy today whether it intended to apply for planning permission for production from the BRX4Z sidetrack well and, if so, when this was expected. We also asked the company whether it still intended, as stated in October, to begin production from the Kimmeridge layers in the first quarter of 2018. This post will be updated with any response.




28 replies »

  1. Councils are NOT authorised to give any company production licence, they can only approve the testing phase. Oil and Gas Authority (OGA) is the Govt organisation responsible for issuing production licence. I think drill drop should stop misleading the public! According to FCA, its a serious offence.

  2. Dear Rihad
    Thank you for your comment.
    You are quite right to say that councils cannot authorise a production licence. But DrillOrDrop did not state that they do and did not mislead the public.
    Mineral Planning Authorities – in this case Surrey County Council – do determine planning applications for the various stages of oil and gas development, including production.
    The National Planning Policy Framework (link here: ) sets out how mineral planning authorities should determine these applications.
    This article outlined the likely content of the Angus Energy planning application based on the screening opinion from the council.
    DrillOrDrop has previously reported on planning applications for production by Egdon Resources at the Wressle site in Lincolnshire and UKOG at Markwells Wood in West Sussex. This week, UKOG announced it would be applying for planning permission for oil production at Horse Hill, also in Surrey. Link here:
    Best wishes, Ruth

    • Hi Chris. Thanks for your comment. The application won’t go online at either Mole Valley or SCC until the SCC planners have verified it. The application will be verified only when the planners are satisfied they have all the information they need. The holiday may have delayed this process, I would imagine. I’ll check with the council on Tuesday 2 January when t expects the details to be published. Best wishes, Ruth

Add a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s