Scottish fracking announcement is “momentous win” but needs to go further – Friends of the Earth Scotland

Scottish Parliament 170531 Friends of the Earth Scotland 2

Friends of the Earth delivering consultation responses to Paul Wheelhouse in May 2017. Photo: Friends of the Earth Scotland

Friends of the Earth Scotland welcomed this afternoon’s announcement by the Scottish Government to extend indefinitely the moratorium on fracking. But the organisation said it would be pushing for a stronger law.

The organisation said:

“Today’s decision is a truly momentous win for the anti-fracking movement, as Scotland joins the ever-growing list of states and regions to outlaw the industry.

“It will be met with celebration and relief across the country, particularly by those on the frontline of fracking here in Scotland who have been working for a ban these last 6 years. It will also be met with cheers around the world, in the many countries and communities who have supported our struggle, many of whom are still fighting their own.

“In his statement to Parliament this afternoon Energy Minister Paul Wheelhouse said that the existing moratorium would be extended indefinitely using planning and environmental regulation powers to effectively ban the fracking industry.

“It fell short of committing to passing a law like recent bans in Ireland, Victoria and Maryland, when powers over onshore oil and gas licensing are finally handed over by Westminster. The measures announced today are the right interim approach, however we will be pushing them to go further and pass a law as soon as licensing powers are technically transferred to Holyrood.”

Our Forth Against Unconventional Gas

“Our Forth welcomes the indefinite moratorium on fracking in Scotland and the Scottish Government is to be congratulated on listening to the people of Scotland. However we believe this decision is also a missed opportunity.

“In the consultation Our Forth argued for a total ban. Fracking, coal bed methane and underground coal gasification have huge impacts on health and the natural environment. They also run counter to any plan to reduce carbon emissions as part of a long-term energy strategy designed to tackle the climate crisis. A continuing moratorium leaves open the possibility that fracking may happen in the future and will continue to create uncertainty for communities across the central belt and in South West Scotland.

“Our Forth pledges to continue to campaign against all forms of Unconventional Gas Extraction until such times as the Scottish Government introduces a total ban and will scrutinise the progress the Scottish Government makes towards an outright ban which the Scottish people so clearly demands. In addition Our Forth stands in solidarity with local communities in England and around the world who are fighting to prevent fracking in their local areas. We will continue to support their campaigns until the threat of fracking is removed.”

Huge win – Greenpeace UK

Elisabeth Whitebread, Energy Campaigner at Greenpeace UK, said:

“The Scottish Government ban on fracking is a huge win for thousands of people who have campaigned against fracking for six years. Unlike Westminster, Holyrood is listening to public opinion. We already have more gas than we can afford to burn, and as well as damaging the climate, fracking will cause local noise, air and light pollution.

“By announcing an outright ban on this new fossil fuel industry in Scotland, and using a fair process to reach their decision, the SNP Government is leading the way towards the clean energy system that people want. The Conservative Government in Westminster is now alone in backing fracking and looks very isolated indeed. Across England, growing numbers of local people will continue to oppose fracking and the failure of democracy on this issue. The Conservatives in Westminster should stop chasing fracked gas, that we don’t need, and that the overwhelming majority don’t want.”

Breaking news on the statement

Reaction from the Scottish Parliament

Industry reaction

Reaction from English campaign groups



12 replies »

  1. A big win for anti frackers. Those in Westminster now will be under pressure to follow the SNP. The fracking industry is not doing a good job to dispel the fear campaign by the antis and not making progress to show the economic benefits and demonstrate its safety in real time. Not a good sign for investment in UK shale.

  2. Well done Friends Of The Earth Scotland, a magnificent job.
    Hmmm, time for a referendum on fracking in England isnt it? Fraxit here we come.

  3. Sanity at last prevails: Scottish Government appears to have resisted INEOS blackmail. A win for the climate, for the poor, for all.

  4. The SNP are running out of ideas hence why their vote collapsed at the last election. Voters for the SNP can generally be identified by sight, they despise the English and believe Westminster to be the root of all evil. Had the SNP won the independence referendum Scotland would be in the same category as Greece. This is not a ban but a mere continuation of what we already had, if the SNP wanted to ban it outright they had the opportunity to do so. I would suggest the antis are rejoicing over zilch. Once it has sunk in the antis will realise the SNP have STILL left the door slightly open and you have to ask why?

    • Peeny we get that you are very upset but what guff is this: “Voters for the SNP can generally be identified by sight”? Sounds a bit like your prejudices are getting the better of you again 😉

      • I tested out my theory during the independence referendum. I’d say a 99% success rate. Hobson you don’t understand Scottish politics so just leave it at that.

    • Don’t be bitter GBH, problem is your theories are off the map regarding Scotland. You should know that they’re a proud, pace-setting nation when it comes to science, engineering and innovation. From James Watt (steam engine pioneer) who kick started the industrial revolution to John Logie Beard (television) and beyond, they’ve led in many areas of innovation. Centuries ago they had five universities when England only had two. I’m confident that they’re showing great intelligence and foresight in this decision and not just turning up their noses at the thought of contaminated water in their whisky.

Add a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s