Legal

Under half the arrests at N Yorks fracking protest resulted in convictions

171021 km rig occupy 5

Occupation of the rig on Third Energy’s fracking site at Kirby Misperton, 21 October 2017. Photo: Kirby Misperton Protection Camp

Data from a Yorkshire law firm shows that less than half the arrests made at protests outside Third Energy’s fracking site ended in a conviction.

Helen White, of Howells Solicitors, who compiled the figures, said some people were charged with offences where there was “no reasonable prospect of a conviction”. Some people were arrested, in cases several times, and either no action was taken against them or they were acquitted or the charges dropped.

The figures cover protests outside the Kirby Misperton site between September 2017 and March 2018. This period coincided with the arrival of fracking equipment at the site and the later demobilisation after the government insisted on a financial resilience assessment of Third Energy.

Now that all the court cases have finished, the Howells data shows there were 85 arrests and 41 convictions.

Of the 85 arrests, 22 did not result in charges. These cases comprised three cautions and 19 cases where no further action was taken.

Of the people charged, 13 cases were discontinued before the case came to court. Another nine cases resulted in not-guilty verdicts after a trial. The conviction figures included cases where some charges had been discontinued.

181001Howells KM arrest data

Ms White, who defended many people who were arrested at Kirby Misperton, said:

“The 50% acquittal rate shows that some cases were charged that had no reasonable prospect of a conviction and were dropped by the prosecution.

“All cases that proceeded to trial were robustly defended with detailed arguments on the right to protest, police powers, and disclosure issues.

“The right to protest is being slowly eroded, and in my opinion, the protesters will be vindicated by history both at Kirby Misperton and around the country. They are passionately against this industry, and they are raising awareness nationally about the dangers of fracking.”

Eddie Thornton, a protester who was arrested several times at Kirby Misperton, said:

“It’s not surprising to see such a low conviction rate. Arrests at protests are often made to remove individuals from the area.

“I was arrested four times, which allowed the police to convince the judge I posed a threat of re-offending. So he banned me from the entire Habton Road which leads to the fracking site.

“All charges against me were later dropped, but the police managed to keep me away from the protest for nine months”.

Another opponent of Third Energy’s operation, Leigh Coghill, was arrested three times but left York Magistrates Court last week (28/9/2018) with a clean record. She said:

“This whole process has been a massive waste of time and money. While the justice system is being cut to the bone, the court has had to appoint a special district judge who’s spent almost a year on these trials. And a year later, thanks to the courageous civil disobedience that took place over many months, Kirby Misperton remains un-fracked.”

North Yorkshire Police published the additional costs of the policing operation. The most recent total, up to February 2018, was £700,660.

A spokesperson for North Yorkshire Police told DrillOrDrop:

“Throughout the operation, our role has been to balance the rights of everyone at Kirby Misperton – including people assembling and protesting peacefully, businesses carrying out their lawful activity, and local residents going about their daily lives safely and without disruption. We responded proportionately to protests, and worked with the protesters to explain what was acceptable in terms of safety and reasonableness.

“However, as the judge said following one trial, ‘rights are not trump cards that can simply be played to deny the rights of other people’. So when the balance tipped from peaceful protest to deliberate, unlawful acts that caused unreasonable disruption to others, we had to take appropriate action.

“The local Neighbourhood Policing Team continues to work in Kirby Misperton and surrounding villages, with ongoing support from local residents to keep our communities safe.”

The North Yorkshire Police figures for arrests and court outcomes were slightly different to those compiled by Howells. The force included an arrest in Whitby in its total. But the  number of convictions was still just under half the number of arrests.

181001 NYP arrest data

The conviction rate, defined by the Crown Prosecution Service as the number of defendants divided by the number of defendants prosecuted, was 66% on the North Yorkshire Police figures and 65% on the Howells figures. The average for England and Wales in magistrates courts in 2017 was 84%.

Analysis by DrillOrDrop of arrests at the Balcombe protests in 2013 found that there had been 126 arrests, 114 charges, 29 convictions and a conviction rate of 25%.

 

 

13 replies »

  1. Hardly surprising.

    If you look at other protests it is quite common for the police to use their powers of arrest to diffuse a situation, and then a prosecution does not always follow.

    However, the situation is diffused and others are left unaware if they are arrested whether they will be prosecuted, or not.

    Would be much better if the police were not having to be there and not having to take this action to protect those going about their legal business.

  2. Isn’t a caution classed as a conviction?
    Accepting a caution is an admission of guilt and means you do not have go to court for that offence.
    Cautions are spent after five years from receiving it, but show up on a CRB check for life.

  3. R8, 34 cases fell by the wayside and did not even make it to court. Usually for lack of evidence, improper arrest or other failings. Conviction rates are 20% lower that the average for England and Wales.

  4. Shut this industry down and there will be zero arrests. Then we can all concentrate our time on doing useful stuff, like reducing our energy needs and supporting renewable energy. The forecasts for jobs as a result of taking this approach far exceed anything from this industry (check Labour conference) and will also help with the imperative need to address climate change.

  5. Did Abbott do the maths. Malcolm?

    You are welcome to believe such twaddle. Others will notice the plans to increase airport and refinery capacity (for starters) where business has identified what energy needs are going to be for the UK. All these new houses being built and planned-what source of heating being fitted?

    So, increased costs of energy is going to create jobs!?? Anyone remember the 1970s? Err-business has to be competitive to create jobs. If their energy costs are much higher than their competitors they sack people to try and compete. So, we end up with the country covered in wind turbines but other businesses put out of business. True to form, Labour always puts people out of work.

    Reality versus fiction.

    • And others will notice the Committee on Climate Change comments regarding the impact that a third runway will have on the government’s binding carbon reduction targets. Lord Deben has stated “there is no room for fracking”.Then just as one example there is all the investment and jobs created by Siemens, manufacturing windturbines and of course there is a whole offshore industry erecting and maintaining turbines. The necessary change to low carbon technology is bound to create jobs and skill transition opportunities for others. Given the direction of world to reduce reliance on fossil fuels, reduce carbon and embrace green technology, I doubt business will be permitted to simply continue as now, nor would it be wise. The transition will not happen overnight but it has already started and will continue faster than some believe. Look at Volvo all cars will be electric or hybrid by 2019. If anything some industries are responding far quicker than our government!

  6. Only half resulted in conviction for bad public behaviour?? Well they certainly did better than our MPs during question times in the Parliament.

  7. The police have clearly been shown by due legal process to have failed to strike either fairness or balance. It is a serious matter arresting and detaining a person. It is worrying that so many arrests were made where the grounds for arrest could not be upheld or proven. I assure you the CPS will not be pleased with the acquittal rate nor the conviction rate. Ms White is correct in her conclusion.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.