2019 election manifesto review

pnr 190916 slider Ros Wills

Preston New Road, 16 September 2019. Photo: Ros Wills

DrillOrDrop’s summary of the election manifesto commitments on fracking and onshore oil and gas. We’ll update this post with each new manifesto.

SNP – “no support for fracking and no new fracking licences”

SNP manifesto

27 November 2019

Key points

  • No support for unconventional oil and gas in Scotland and no new licences for fracking or coal bed methane
  • Ring fence oil and gas receipts in a net zero fund to invest in renewable energy and carbon capture and storage
  • Net zero carbon emissions by 2040 and net zero of all emissions by 2045

The Scottish National Party manifesto restated the party’s policy of no support for unconventional oil and gas and fracking in Scotland. It said:

“This means the Scottish Government will not issue licences for new unconventional oil and gas development, and that Scotland’s planning framework will not support development using unconventional oil and gas extraction techniques, including coal bed methane and hydraulic fracturing, commonly known as ‘fracking’.”

The SNP manifesto called for a net zero fund to ring-fence oil and gas revenues, estimated at £85bn in the five years to 2023-4. This fund, the SNP said, would help to fund energy transition through investment in renewable energy, electric vehicles and carbon capture utilisation and storage.

The manifesto said 12% of the fund, at least £1bn over five years, would help diversify economies of oil hubs like Aberdeen, Falkirk and Shetland.

The SNP said it would press the UK government to accelerate action to decarbonise the gas grid and ensure that all new homes from 2024 must use renewable or low carbon heat.

The UK government should “properly support” the renewables industry or devole power to Scotland, the manifesto said. It opposed new nuclear power plants  and proposed reform of UK support for renewables. Onshore wind and solar should be allowed to bid for the UK’s main renewables support mechanism.

The SNP also proposed a green energy deal to give green energy projects long-term certainty. It would also provide adequate funding for a wave and tidal energy strategy. The manifesto promised to press the Conservatives to end plans to increase VAT on home solar.

On climate change action, the party said it would demand the UK met Scottish targets of a 75% reduction in emissions by 2030 and net zero by 2040.

The SNP said it would also press for accelerated deployment of fully operational carbon capture utilisation and storage facilities in Scotland.

SNP manifesto

Conservatives – “no support for fracking unless science shows categorically it can be done safely”

24 November 2019

Key points

  • No support for fracking
  • Support for gas for hydrogen production
  • Commitment to protect and enhance the green belt and action against encampments
191124 Boris Johnson manifesto Conservative Party

Boris Johnson. Photo: Conservative Party

The Conservative manifesto restated the moratorium on fracking in England, announced by the government with immediate effect earlier this month. It added:

“We will not support fracking unless the science shows categorically that it can be done safely.”

The manifesto also confirmed the previous government announcement against changing the planning system for shale gas schemes, proposed in the 2017 Conservative manifesto.

There was no specific reference to onshore oil and gas or other forms of unconventional extraction. But the manifesto did say:

“We will support gas for hydrogen production, and nuclear energy, including fusion, as important parts of the energy system, alongside increasing our commitment to renewables.”

The manifesto promised to “protest and enhance the Green Belt”, the location of several onshore oil and gas planning plans and applications.

It also said it would “lead the global fight against climate change by delivering on our world-leading target of Net Zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050.”

The document said:

“We will use our position hosting the UN Climate Change Summit in Glasgow in 2020 to ask our global partners to match our ambition.”

The first budget would “prioritise the environment”, the Conservatives said, with investment in research and development, decarbonisation, new flood defences (£4bn over “coming years”), electric vehicle infrastructure and clean energy.

The party committed to:

  • Establish a £500m blue planet fund to “help protect our oceans from plastic pollution, warming sea temperatures and overfishing”
  • Lower energy bills by investing £9.6bn in energy efficiency for homes, schools and hospitals.First budget will
  • Invest £800m in the first fully deployed carbon capture storage cluster by the mid-2020s
  • Invest £500m to help energy-intensive industries move to low-carbon technologies

There were also commitments to support clean transport, consult on phasing out new conventional petrol and diesel cars, ban export of plastic waste to non-OECD countries, and work with market to deliver two million new jobs in “clean growth”.

The party promised new powers that could be used against protest, protection and monitoring camps. The manifesto said:

“We will give the police new powers to arrest and seize the property and vehicles of trespassers who set up unauthorised encampments, in order to protect our communities. We will make intentional trespass a criminal offence, and we will also give councils greater powers within the planning system.”

Conservative Party manifesto


170707 pnr Cheryl Atkinson2

Photo: Cheryl Atkinson

plaid cymru logoPlaid Cymru – “Carbon and single use plastic free by 2030”

22 November 2019

Plaid Cymru promised to:

“seek a complete ban on fracking and new open cast coal mines”.

Wales would make the transition to 100% self-sufficient in renewable energy by 2030, the manifesto said.

The party committed to tidal lagoons for Swansea, Cardiff and Colwyn Bays, a wind farm off Ynys Mon and an Usk barrage. There would also be a network of local energy grids for Wales and changes to planning legislation to fast-track community-owned energy schemes.

A national energy agency, Ynni Cymru, would be charged with realising Wales’s green energy potential. The party promised to oppose the development of new sites for nuclear power stations.

The manifesto also promised a “Welsh green jobs revolution”:

“Create tens of thousands of new jobs throughout Wales by kick-starting a multi-billion investment programme in renewable energy, transport infrastructure and digital technology, with the goal of making Wales a carbon and single-use plastic free national by 2030.”

A £5bn greener homes programme would improve energy efficiency in Welsh homes and reduce fuel poverty, the manifesto said. And an expanded Trans Cymru bus network of high-quality coaches would be powered by renewable energy.

Plaid Cymru manifesto

Brexit Party logoBrexit Party – “zero-rate VAT on fuel bills”

22 November 2019

The Brexit Party’s “contract with the people” had no references to fracking, oil, gas, hydrocarbons, onshore exploration, drilling, climate or greenhouse gases.

On energy, the party committed to zero rate VAT on domestic fuel to reduce energy bills

It also promised to plant “millions of trees to capture CO2” and recycle the UK’s waste, making it illegal to export across the world.

The Brexit Party contract with the people

Labour – “net zero carbon energy within the 2030s”

21 November 2019

Key points

  • Immediate and permanent ban on fracking
  • Nearly 90% of electricity and 50% of heat from renewable and low carbon sources by 2030
  • Windfall tax on oil companies
pnr 190730 Jeremy Corbyn Refracktion1

Labour leader, Jeremy Corbyn, outside Cuadrilla’s Preston New Road site, 30 July 2019. Photo: Refracktion

Labour repeated its opposition to fracking, describing the process, “pushed through” by the Conservatives, as “dangerous”.

The party said:

“We will expand distributed and community energy, and immediately and permanently ban fracking”.

Unlike the Greens, but along with the Lib Dems, the party had no comment on other forms of unconventional or extreme hydrocarbon extraction.

The manifesto also promised:

“a windfall tax on oil companies, so that the companies that knowingly damaged our climate will help cover the costs.”

Labour said it would “put the UK on track” for a net-zero carbon energy system within the 2030s. It committed to nearly 90% of electricity and 50% of heat from renewable and low-carbon sources by 2030.

The party promised it would build:

  • 7,000 new offshore wind turbines
  • 2,000 new onshore wind turbines
  • Enough solar panels to cover 22,000 football pitches
  • New nuclear power needed for energy security

Labour would also trial tidal energy and invest to reduce the costs of renewable and low-carbon hydrogen production, the manifesto said.

Almost all the UK’s 27 million homes would be upgraded to the highest energy efficiency standards, the party said. It committed to a zero-carbon homes standard for all new homes and a roll-out of heat pumps, solar hot water and hydrogen heating, along with investment in district heat networks.

Labour also promised to expand power storage and invest in enhancements and interconnectors for the national electricity grid.

The manifesto said the party would launch a £400bn national transformation fund, of which £250bn would go to renewable and low carbon energy and transport, as well as biodiversity and environmental restoration. Treasury rules would be rewritten to ensure investments were compatible with climate and environmental targets.

On climate targets, the manifesto said:

“Labour will take full responsibility for our carbon footprint instead of passing the buck.

“We will instruct the Committee on Climate Change to assess the emissions the UK imports as well as those it produces, and recommend policies to tackle them, including making UK industry the greenest in the world.”

On health, the manifesto promised the NHS would become a net-zero carbon service. This would be achieved by:

  • NHS Forest of one million trees
  • More efficient heating and insulation systems
  • Greater reliance on renewable energy, including more solar panels
  • Transition to electric paramedic vehicles, NHS fleet cars and hybrid ambulances

On transport, the manifesto promised a review of public expenditure to ensure it promoted environmental sustainability and contributed to decarbonisation. Among the commitments were:

  • Free bus travel for under 25s where councils take control of buses
  • Reinstate 3,000 routes that have been cut
  • Bring railways back into public ownership
  • Promote the use of rail freight
  • Complete HS2 to Scotland
  • Air quality, noise pollution and climate tests for airport expansion

Labour manifesto (pdf)

Yorkshire Party – “total regional ban on fracking”

21 November 2019

Yorkshire Party logo

The Yorkshire Party promises net zero carbon emissions across Yorkshire by 2030. This would, the party said, be achieved by:

  • Region-wide, total, ban on fracking
  • Offset legacy CO2 emissions by planting six million trees
  • Decarbonise heat and transport by investing in hydrogen and offshore wind

The party also committed to building 23,000 new energy-efficient homes every year for the next 20 years, of which 8,000 would be available at social rent levels.

191121 Yorkshire Party manifesto

Liberal Democrats – “only party with radical, credible plan to tackle climate emergency”

20 November 2019

Key points

  • Ban fracking for good
  • Generate 80% of electricity by renewables by 2030
  • End fossil fuel subsidies by 2025
191120 Lib Dem manifesto image

Image: Liberal Democrats

The Lib Dems today pledged to ban “fracking for good”

The party’s manifesto promised a ban

“because of its negative impacts on climate change, the energy mix and the local environment”.

But unlike the Greens, it did not have proposals for any other form of unconventional fossil fuel extraction.

The Lib Dem manifesto said it was:

“the only party with a radical, credible and detailed plan to tackle the climate emergency as soon as possible”.

It promised a 10-year “emergency programme to cut greenhouse gas emissions substantially straightaway and phase out emissions from the remaining hard-to-treat sectors by 2045.

This would be achieved by:

  • Emergency programme to insulate all Britain’s homes by 2030
  • 80% of UK electricity generated from renewables by 2030
  • Legally-binding target to reduce net greenhouse gas emissions to zero by 2045

The manifesto said all UK registered and stock-market listed companies would be required to set climate change targets consistent with the Paris Agreement and report on their implementation. Financial services would be regulated to encouraged green investments.

The Lib Dems said they would establish a Department for Climate Change and Natural Resources and coordinate government-wide action for a zero-carbon economy under a cabinet-level minister.

Other initiatives included:

  • UK and local citizens’ climate assemblies on the climate emergency
  • Requirement on local authorities to produce zero-carbon strategy
  • Create an Office of Environmental Protection independent of government with powers to enforce compliance with climate and environmental targets
  • Increase government spending on climate and environmental objectives to reach 5% in five years
  • Create a new Green Investment Bank to support investment in zero carbon technology
  • End fossil fuel subsidies by 2025 in line with G7 pledge

On electricity generation, the manifesto promised £12bn over five years to accelerate deployment of renewable power. The party would remove Conservative restrictions on wind and solar and build more interconnectors. All new homes would be fitted with solar panels and investment wold be supported in tidal and wave energy, storage, demand response, smart grids and hydrogen technologies.

On housing, the manifesto said the Lib Dems would cut energy bills, end fuel poverty by 2025 and reduce emissions from buildings. Other proposals included reduction in VAT on home insulation and a graduation on stamp duty by the energy rating of a property. All new homes must be built to a zero-carbon standard by 2021.

On industry, the Lib Dems promised to reduce emissions by supporting carbon capture and storage and new low-carbon processes for cement and steel production. The party said it would end support from UK Export Finance for fossil fuel-related activities.

Non-recyclable single-use plastics would be banned and replaced with affordable alternatives. The party said it aimed for complete elimination in three years and an end to plastic waste exports by 2030.

Lib Dem manifesto (pdf)

Green Party – “stop burning fossil fuels as soon as possible”

19 November 2019

Key points

  • Ban fracking and other unconventional fossil fuel extraction 
  • Remove subsidies for oil and gas
  • Apply carbon tax to imports and domestic production of fossil fuels
pnr 180614 Jonathan Bartley Tina Rotheryedit

Jonathan Bartley outside Cuadrilla’s Preston New Road site, 14 June 2018. Photo: Tina Rothery

As expected, the Green Party restated its commitment to oppose fracking. The party’s Green New Deal for energy said it would:

“Ban fracking, and other unconventional forms of fossil fuel extraction, now and forever.”

The party also said it would:

  • Remove subsides to oil and gas
  • Apply a progressively increasing carbon tax on all fossil fuel imports and domestic extraction based on greenhouse gas emissions produced when fuel is burnt.

The tax would make coal, oil and gas financial unviable within a decade, the party said.

The manifesto said the 2019 election was voters’ chance to put the climate emergency at the top of the political agenda. The aim was to reduce UK carbon emissions to net zero by 2030:

“The key to reducing our impact on the climate is to stop burning fossil fuels as soon as possible.”

It said the UK had abundant wind, tides, sun and rivers to be self-sufficient in energy.

“It’s time for investment to unleash this potential and enable us leave oil and gas in the ground.

“With our renewable energy supply unlocked, we can hugely reduce fossil fuel use in our energy system and with it our reliance on nuclear power.”

The Green Party said its New Deal would also:

  • Enable communities to develop their own renewable energy projects
  • Introduce new support and incentives to accelerate wind energy development to produce 70% of UK electricity by 2030
  • Introduce new support for other renewable energies to provide the remaining 30%.
  • Transform the planning system to support a massive increase in wind and other renewables
  • Open up more coastal water for offshore wind and marine energy
  • Connect UK electricity supply more closely to European neighbours to provide wider supply when needed and exports during a surplus
  • Improve the efficiency and capacity of the electricity grid
  • Expand capacity for short-term electricity storage
  • Prohibit construction of nuclear power stations
  • Encourage greater energy efficiency

On housing, the Green Party said it would

“Reduce the use of natural gas for heating homes through a programme, to replace polluting boilers with renewable heat from heat pumps, and solar thermal, geothermal, biomass and stored heat technologies.”

Other measures included energy efficiency improvements in homes, insulation of non-domestic buildings, roll-out of solar panels and incentivise renovation and improvement of existing buildings, rather than new build.

In industry, the party said it would prepare for a rapid decommissioning of North Sea oil rigs.

Green Party manifesto (pdf)

50 replies »

  1. Factcheck:

    The Tories will not PROTEST the Green Belt, but Freud would be pleased to see his work supported!

    “No doubt”?? Except first deliveries of LNG imports into Pembrokeshire from USA to fuel the local power station commenced within the last few weeks.

    (This service was brought to you by a totally independent source.)LOL

Add a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s