Don’t bail out fossil fuels in Covid recovery – UK Climate Assembly members

190102 Tinker Lane Eric Walton 2

Drone footage of Tinker Lane, Nottinghamshire, 2 January 2019. Photo: Eric Walton

The UK’s Climate Assembly has said government plans for economic recovery from the coronavirus outbreak should also help achieve net zero carbon emissions.

Assembly members advised ministers against bailing out oil and gas companies in the economic stimulus. Some said the industry was incompatible with net zero and support would be a waste of money.

Investment in high carbon industries should be limited or given only with conditions, members said.

An interim briefing from the assembly, published today, also reveals that almost all members felt government and employers should encourage people to change their lifestyles to be more compatible with reaching net zero.

The assembly is made up of 108 people who were selected to be representative of the demographics of the UK population and the levels of concern about climate change. They were asked to explore how the UK should reach its legally-binding target of net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050.

Today’s briefing is expected to inform the Committee on Climate Change’s annual progress report to parliament, due later this week, and the chancellor’s economic stimulus, expected before the summer recess.

A group of leading MPs have urged the government to take the assembly’s views into account in its new policies.

One of the assembly expert advisers, Professor Jim Watson, of University College London, described the briefing as a unique insight into the views of an informed and representative sample of the UK population.

200622 UK Climate Assembly chart 1

The briefing reveals that 79% of assembly members agreed or strongly agreed that steps taken by the government to help the economy recovery should be designed to help achieve net zero emissions.

Those who agreed with the statement called on the government to:

  • Limit or put conditions on investment in high carbon industries
  • Support low carbon industries
  • Rethink and invest in infrastructure
  • Make the most of economic opportunities presented by the path towards net zero

Only 9% disagreed or strongly disagreed with the statement. 12% were unsure.

The briefing included quotes from assembly members to help explain their thinking. One person said:

“Any money spent bailing out dying fossil fuel industries is money wasted on industries that won’t survive anyway.”

Another said:

“I don’t think oil or gas companies should be given bailouts, you’re wanting to stop them anyway, so why support them – support the people who work for them but not the companies – that’s because they aren’t compatible with net zero.”

One member recommended:

“Avoiding lock in of fossil fuel use [is] key – best chance to do this is now to avoid going back into the trap of fossil fuels again. That would be disappointing.”

The briefing included other points of view. One person said:

“Some fossil fuel sectors bring in a lot of money so it’s hard not to support them.”

Another proposed:

“Because oil is cheap – put a tax on oil.”

200622 UK Climate Assembly chart 2

The briefing also revealed that 93% of assembly members agreed or strongly agreed that as the lockdown eases, government, employers and others should take steps to encourage lifestyles to change to be more compatible with reaching net zero.

4% disagreed or strong disagreed. 3% were unsure.

Changes most frequently recommended included:

  • Encourage home working and changes to how we travel
  • Encourage cycling, making it safer and providing proper infrastructure
  • Reduce the need for business travel, particularly flying

One assembly member said:

“Home working is brilliant – less traffic, less flights, quicker – government have to encourage it somehow either with incentives or penalties.”

Another said:

“There is a great opportunity to restart the economy on a greener pathway and such chances should be seized upon.”

The chairs of six parliamentary select committees, which commissioned the Climate Assembly UK, wrote to the prime minister today urging the government to take account of the briefing. Their letter said:

“It is vital that achieving the UK’s net zero target, which has unanimous cross-party support, is a joint endeavour between the Government, Parliament and the public across the country.

“In recent months the UK public has demonstrated its capacity to respond positively and responsibly when they understand the risks posed to them by an invisible threat that demands collective action.

“We believe that a similar approach, based on securing public support for ambitious policies through open dialogue around the science, is a sound basis for the net zero journey.”

  • The Climate Assembly met for six weekends between late January and later May 2020. Its consideration of the Covid-19 recover came on the final weekend. The assembly’s final report is due to be published in September 2020.

5 replies »

  1. I was surprised that an assembly member, one who advises ģov it seems, is blissfully unaware that oil is already taxed in the uk. Both production and consumption.
    A quote out of context maybe or ( as private eye would say) shome mistake surely?

  2. How did they meet in May 2020??

    I thought there were restrictions upon gatherings in May 2020. Maybe it was virtual, utilising those nasty fossil fuels many were so keen to eradicate? Turkeys and Christmas come to mind.

    Lifestyle changes made me smile. I recall the days the paperless office was offered by the utilisation of modern technology. Hmm, apart from a few isolated incidents, that has been a raging success-NOT.
    Business flights was another. Yes, there are ways business trips can be minimised, (costs and margins did that some while ago), yet Covid-19 has been full of reminders about the importance of human contact. That relates to all relationships-including business. All those unemployed body language experts if everyone worked from home and never met a client!

Add a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s