The Environment Agency has granted a permit for gas drilling and lower-volume fracking plans in the North Yorkshire village of Burniston.

In an online update yesterday, the regulator said:
“Following completion of our assessment and consideration of all consultation responses, we have decided to grant the environmental permit.
“This decision is based on the applicant demonstrating that it has met the applicable legal and environmental requirements for the proposed activity and that it will be able to carry out the permitted activity within the conditions set out in the permit. The permit contains legally enforceable conditions.”
The decision has disappointed the local campaign group, Frack Free Coastal Communities (see “Disappointed but not surprised“). It has criticised the Burniston permitting process and accused the EA of “collusion” with Europa Oil & Gas, the company behind the plans.
There have also been formal complaints about the process by Burniston Parish Council and an oil and gas campaigner, Dennis May.
The parish council questioned the EA’s appearance of impartiality and its ability to reach decisions through “a fair, transparent and evidence-based process”.
Mr May, who is seeking a management review of his formal complaint, accused the EA of a “wholesale failure in quality assurance” in the permit process.
The EA revised its draft decision last month (October 2026) after residents and campaigners pointed out errors, inconsistencies and missing information. Some local people complained that they did not have time to respond to the revised documents before the public consultation deadline on 21 October 2026.
The permit and decision document will be published online, the EA said. At the time of writing, they were not available. Europa has identified its proposed well as Cloughton-2.
Company response
In a statement to investors this morning, Europa’s chief executive, William Holland, said:
“I’m pleased that the Environment Agency, the independent regulator responsible for protecting the environment, has assessed our plans in detail and issued the permit for the Cloughton appraisal well, concluding that our proposed operations meet the requirements of environmental legislation.”
The permit process is separate from planning consent, decided by North Yorkshire Council. The council’s planning committee refused Europa’s planning application in May 2026. The company has now appealed.
Mr Holland also said:
“Our planning application was supported by 13 independent expert reports and recommended for approval by North Yorkshire Council’s own professional planning officers. While we respect the role of the planning committee, we believe that the reasons for refusal are not supported by the technical evidence or the relevant planning policy.
“The planning system is designed to ensure that decisions are grounded in sound technical evidence and established planning policy, while giving appropriate consideration to the views of local communities.
“We have enjoyed our engagement with the local communities and authorities and very much respect the rights of all to express their views on our plans and we support and have actively engaged in that process. We believe that an objective assessment of our application against the process’s principles provides a compelling case for approval and we look forward to demonstrating this through the appeals process.”
Mr Holland repeated his view that UK onshore oil and gas regulation was “one of the strictest in the world”.
He added:
“A successful appraisal well that leads to the development of the Cloughton gas field will result in domestic gas production delivered into the UK gas network, providing local employment, generating taxes for HMRC and reducing the UK’s reliance on imported gas, including LNG, which on average has a far higher production and transport carbon intensity than UK-produced gas. We believe this is in the best interests of both the local community and the country as a whole.”
“Disappointed but not surprised” – campaign group
Professor Chris Garforth, chair of the Frack Free Coastal Communities steering group, said today:
“We are disappointed that the EA took so little time to dismiss the significant issues raised by FFCC and others during the consultation. Disappointed but not surprised, given what we now know about the collusion between the EA and Europa over the wording of the permit and the pre-operation conditions.
“The continuing errors and omissions in the EA’s consultation documents have not been addressed. The astonishing relegation of missing data to pre-operation conditions allows the company and the EA to avoid further public scrutiny of issues which are at the heart of local concerns about the project.
“Mr Holland’s statement to the stock exchange is depressingly predictable. He repeats his mantra that ‘13 independent reports’ support Europa’s proposals omitting to mention that these were commissioned by Europa and several were found to contain material errors of fact and methodology.
“He also heaps praise on the regulatory environment for onshore oil and gas in the UK – an environment which Europa have been adept at exploiting to avoid full scrutiny of their plans. He is blatant in his ambition to develop a gas field on the Heritage Coast while cloaking himself in the language of a temporary appraisal project.
“We believe that those who live and work in the area and their elected representatives at parish, regional and national levels are better arbiters than fossil fuel executives like Mr Holland of what is ‘in the best interests of … the local community’.
“Our main focus in the weeks ahead is on making sure that the community’s voices are heard loud and clear in the appeal process. We look forward once again to challenging Europa’s claims. The grounds for refusal of planning permission are robustly based on planning policy and guidance. Meanwhile the growing evidence and urgency of the climate crisis, driven by the unrestrained extraction and use of fossil fuels, highlight the need to leave Yorkshire gas where it belongs – deep in the rocks beneath our coastal villages.”
DrillOrDrop will update this article with other reaction when we get it.
Categories: Regulation, slider